How to Choose the Right Executor for Your Estate

By Goldstein Mauer PLLC
Old couples discussing estate plan with attorney

When planning your estate, one of the most important decisions you'll make is selecting the right executor. This person will be responsible for carrying out your wishes, checking that your assets are distributed according to your will, and managing any outstanding obligations. 

Choosing the wrong individual for this task can lead to confusion, delays, and potential conflict among beneficiaries. It's essential to think carefully about who will best fulfill the role. Goldstein Mauer PLLC can help those in New York City and the surrounding areas make smart choices when estate planning. Read on to learn more.

What Does an Executor Do?

Before choosing someone for the role of executor, it's useful to first understand what the job entails. The executor is the individual named in your will to administer your estate after your death. They’re tasked with overseeing a number of responsibilities, such as gathering and appraising assets, paying debts and taxes, and distributing property to your beneficiaries.

Executors also handle the filing of your will with the probate court, if necessary, and can represent the estate in legal matters. Depending on the state or country in which you live, these duties may be more or less extensive. However, it’s generally a detailed and time-consuming process that requires both organizational skills and a sense of responsibility.

Factors to Consider When Choosing an Executor

Choosing the right executor isn’t about simply picking someone you trust. While trust is important, you’ll need to evaluate a few other factors to make sure the person is up to the task. Below are some of the key considerations that can guide you in your decision-making process.

Trustworthiness and Integrity

The executor you choose will be responsible for making sure your wishes are carried out correctly. This includes seeing that your beneficiaries receive their inheritance as outlined in your will. 

For this reason, the individual you select must be someone you trust completely. You need someone who will act impartially, without bias toward any one beneficiary, and who will follow the guidelines set out in your estate planning documents. 

Trustworthiness and integrity are essential because the executor may face challenges, both from within your family and from external sources, and must be able to act ethically and in line with your wishes, regardless of personal feelings or relationships.

Organizational Skills

Managing an estate requires the ability to keep track of various documents, assets, and deadlines. The executor will need to organize the collection of personal property, real estate, financial accounts, and debts. This may involve contacting multiple institutions, reviewing financial records, and working with professionals such as accountants or attorneys.

If you’re considering someone who may not be particularly organized, it may be a good idea to reconsider, as this role demands a certain level of efficiency. A disorganized executor could delay the process or make mistakes that may be difficult to rectify later. Good organizational skills are a fundamental attribute for anyone in this role.

Availability and Time Commitment

Serving as an executor can take anywhere from a few months to several years, depending on the size and intricacy of your estate. The person you choose must be available to dedicate time to the estate’s management. You should consider their current life commitments, such as work, family, and health, and whether they’re in a position to take on the responsibility.

An executor must be able to address issues as they arise, sometimes on short notice. If you choose someone with a busy schedule or a demanding job, it might be difficult for them to give the estate the attention it requires. Make sure the individual can commit to the time and effort necessary for completing the job.

Financial Acumen

Estate planning often involves handling financial assets such as investments, property, insurance policies, and retirement accounts. An executor with financial knowledge or experience in managing financial matters can be very helpful, particularly if your estate includes assets that require specific expertise, such as stocks, bonds, or business interests.

While an executor doesn’t necessarily need to be an accountant or financial planner, they should feel comfortable managing finances and working with professionals who can assist them. If you believe your estate could involve intricate financial issues, selecting an individual with some familiarity with finances can help smooth the process.

Ability to Handle Disputes

Family dynamics can often complicate the estate administration process. Disputes over inheritances, disagreements between beneficiaries, or challenges to the validity of the will aren’t uncommon. An executor must have the temperament to handle such issues with diplomacy and impartiality.

If you believe that your estate might be subject to disputes or tension among beneficiaries, you may want to select someone who is level-headed and able to mediate conflicts effectively. The role requires someone who can remain calm and focused, even when emotions run high.

Familiarity With Your Wishes

An executor should be someone who is familiar with your estate planning intentions. This doesn’t mean they need to know every detail of your plan, but they should have a basic understanding of your goals and the family dynamics involved. 

For example, if you want to provide specific instructions for charitable donations or personal possessions, it’s essential that the executor be aware of those details.

It also helps if the person is comfortable communicating with your beneficiaries and other involved parties. An executor who understands your wishes is better equipped to follow through with your intentions without second-guessing or requiring constant clarification.

Who Should You Consider?

With the important factors above in mind, it’s time to think about potential candidates. Traditionally, individuals often name a close family member, such as a spouse, child, or sibling, as their executor. However, that isn’t the only option. Depending on the nature of your estate and the difficulty of your wishes, there are other potential choices you can consider.

Family Members

Many people choose family members because they’re familiar with your personal life and your values. A child or spouse may understand your wishes better than anyone else and be more invested in carrying them out faithfully. 

However, naming a family member can sometimes create complications, particularly if other family members feel excluded or have a vested interest in the estate. If you opt for a family member, make sure that they’re the right fit in terms of skills and availability. It’s also helpful to have open conversations about the role, so they understand what’s expected of them.

Professional Executors

Some individuals prefer to hire a professional executor, such as an attorney or trust company. These individuals or firms typically have the experience to manage estates, deal with legal matters, and handle financial issues effectively. 

If your estate is large or involves specialized knowledge, a professional may be a smart option to check that all aspects are managed appropriately. The benefit of choosing a professional is that they have a structured approach to estate administration, and they won’t be emotionally involved in any family disputes. 

Close Friends

Sometimes, people opt for close friends when they don't have suitable family members to serve as executors. A trusted friend may have the time, organizational skills, and temperament needed to handle the responsibilities. 

However, like family members, friends can also become embroiled in disputes or face emotional challenges while managing an estate, especially if there are conflicting interests among beneficiaries.

Co-Executors

In some cases, individuals decide to appoint co-executors. This can be helpful when you want to balance the responsibilities between two people. For instance, one might be more organized, while the other has legal knowledge. 

Co-executors can share the workload, but this arrangement can also lead to complications if the individuals disagree on how to proceed. If you choose to name co-executors, make sure they can work well together and that they understand their respective duties.

Communicating With Your Executor

Once you've selected an executor, it’s important to communicate your wishes clearly. While your will serves as a binding legal document, open discussions with your executor can clarify nuances or personal preferences that may not be fully detailed in writing. Clear communication makes sure that your executor understands your goals and intentions.

Consider these steps to help facilitate this process:

  • Discuss your estate plan: Explain the key elements of your plan, including the distribution of assets and any specific instructions.

  • Anticipate potential challenges: Address any family dynamics or potential disputes that could arise, offering guidance on how to manage these issues.

  • Provide practical information: Share details about financial accounts, property, and other assets to streamline administration.

  • Express personal preferences: Convey wishes that may not be explicitly covered in the will, such as sentimental considerations or funeral arrangements.

By having these conversations, you can help minimize confusion and secure a smoother administration process for everyone involved. For further assistance in creating a comprehensive estate plan, contact an attorney today.

Enlist the Support of an Experienced Attorney Today

Whether you choose a family member, a close friend, or a professional, make sure the person you appoint has the skills and qualities necessary to handle your estate. And, most importantly, communicate your wishes clearly so the process is as smooth as possible. Estate planning is about securing your legacy, and selecting the right executor plays a vital part in that process.

Are you ready to choose an executor for your estate? Our firm provides services to the New York City metro area, including the five boroughs (Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island), Long Island, Westchester County, and Rockland County. Goldstein Mauer PLLC is here to help; reach out today for guidance with estate planning.